On Tue, Mar 2, 2010 at 3:29 PM, Marcello Perathoner <marcello@perathoner.de> wrote:
That would very well fly. I don't believe the DP TOS allow you to take a file out and publish it on your own. And if they allow that, I don't understand all the fuss they are making against a PG preprint distribution.
The difference is between something that is tolerated, and an officially sanctioned central repository. Also, I think the arguments for posting text and HTML separately got confused with the arguments about posting earlier in the process. phpBB's threading is... suboptimal. Personally, I'm in the pre-publish camp (after it passes each round, by preference. There's little point in splitting TXT and HTML posting at PP). As well as making p1->p1 opt-out, p3 opt in, parallel f1 opt-out[1], and f2 opt in. R C [1] Means a little more work for the PM to do the merge, but worth it IMO for simpler works. Would need some relatively minor tool or dev support.