On Sun, Nov 25, 2012 at 10:39 AM, Lee Passey <lee@passkeysoft.com> wrote:
So, you have failed to address Mr. Newby's core question, which is "how do we determine the quality of any arbitrary PG edition?" I'm sure that any concrete proposal you would care to make would be genuinely appreciated.
User vote? Set up a page for each work with multiple versions. The page should link to all editions; this is the page that should appear when someone searches for the work. Perhaps add info re date of submission and whether the version has been done by one volunteer or by DP. Ask PG users who have downloaded one or another of the versions, or read enough online to judge, to vote on accuracy and user-friendliness. Over time, the better versions should accumulate more votes. -- Karen Lofstrom