IMO, PG's home page should be neutral territory. It should not be a home for dueling reviews/arguments. Gutvol-d has enough, and usually more than enough, of the latter. For user reviews/experiences, there should/could be a link to them elsewhere on PG's home page, perhaps as articles linked from the "MobileReader Devices How-To" page, or the PG Wiki page (at the bottom of PG's home page), something like the "Volunteers' Voices" on the FAQ page. Al